The main differences in chemical composition between Q390B and Q355B are strategically designed to achieve the ~10% increase in minimum yield strength (from 355 MPa to 390 MPa) while maintaining weldability and toughness. Q390B achieves this through higher amounts of strengthening elements and stricter control of impurities.

Here is a detailed, side-by-side comparison based on GB/T 1591-2018:
Key Composition Comparison Table
(Values are maximum percentages unless specified as a range. Based on standard specifications for thickness ≤ 40mm.)
| Element | Q355B | Q390B | Purpose & Implication of Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carbon (C) | ≤ 0.24% | ≤ 0.20% | Q390B has a lower max carbon. This is critical to control weldability and toughness, as the strength increase comes from other elements. |
| Manganese (Mn) | ≤ 1.60% | ≤ 1.70% | Q390B allows slightly more Mn. Manganese is a primary, cost-effective strengthener and grain refiner. The increase directly contributes to higher strength. |
| Silicon (Si) | ≤ 0.55% | ≤ 0.55% | Similar. Silicon is a deoxidizer and solid solution strengthener. |
| Phosphorus (P) | ≤ 0.035% | ≤ 0.030% | Stricter limit for Q390B. Phosphorus embrittles steel. The lower limit improves overall toughness and resistance to brittle fracture. |
| Sulfur (S) | ≤ 0.035% | ≤ 0.030% | Stricter limit for Q390B. Sulfur forms harmful inclusions (MnS) that reduce ductility and through-thickness properties (Z-direction). Lower sulfur improves weldability and lamellar tearing resistance. |
| Micro-Alloying Elements (V, Nb, Ti) | Optional / May be Added | Often Mandatory / More Utilized | This is the most critical difference. Q390B more consistently relies on precipitation strengthening from these elements: • Vanadium (V): ≤ 0.20% • Niobium (Nb): ≤ 0.07% • Titanium (Ti): ≤ 0.20% These elements form fine carbonitride particles that pin dislocations and grain boundaries, significantly increasing strength without drastic heat treatment. |
| Carbon Equivalent (Ceq) | Typically ~0.40-0.45% | Typically ~0.44-0.49% | Q390B has a higher maximum allowable Ceq. Despite its lower carbon, the combined effect of higher Mn and micro-alloys raises the Ceq. This is the core trade-off: higher strength at the cost of increased hardenability and slightly reduced weldability. |
Practical Implications of These Differences
1. Strength Mechanism
Q355B: Strength comes mainly from solid solution strengthening (Mn, Si) and grain refinement.
Q390B: Strength comes from solid solution strengthening + precipitation strengthening (micro-alloying). This is a more efficient strengthening mechanism, allowing for higher strength without a large increase in carbon.
2. Weldability
Q355B: Excellent weldability. Preheating is often not required for thin-to-medium sections under normal conditions.
Q390B: Good but more demanding weldability. The higher Ceq increases the material's hardenability, raising the risk of forming hard, brittle martensite in the Heat-Affected Zone (HAZ) during welding.
Result: Welding Q390B often requires mandatory preheating, stricter control of heat input, and the use of low-hydrogen welding procedures to prevent hydrogen-induced cold cracking.
3. Toughness & Ductility
Q390B maintains good toughness comparable to Q355B (both guarantee ≥34J at +20°C) due to:
Lower max carbon content.
Stricter limits on P and S (embrittling elements).
Grain refinement from micro-alloys (Nb, Ti).
However, if welding is not properly controlled, the HAZ of Q390B can exhibit lower toughness than Q355B.
4. Fabrication
Cold Forming: Q390B requires slightly more force due to its higher strength.
Flame Cutting & Thermal Processes: Similar to Q355B, but the risk of hardening and cracking at cut edges is slightly higher for Q390B, sometimes necessitating preheating for thick sections.
Summary
The chemical composition differences reflect a deliberate engineering trade-off:
Q355B is optimized for maximum weldability and fabricability with very good strength.
Q390B is optimized for higher strength while maintaining acceptable weldability. It achieves this by relying on micro-alloying (V, Nb) for precipitation hardening, slightly increasing Mn, and simultaneously lowering harmful elements (C, P, S) to compensate for the increased hardenability.
For the designer/fabricator, this means:
Choose Q355B when strength is adequate and ease/cost of fabrication is paramount.
Choose Q390B when the design requires higher strength to reduce weight or size of members, and you can implement the necessary controlled welding procedures.

