Knowledge

A387 Grade 5 Class 2 vs Class 1: Key Differences

Jan 08, 2026 Leave a message

ASTM A387 Grade 5 is a chromium-molybdenum alloy steel plate used for welded pressure vessels operating at elevated temperatures, with a nominal composition of 5% chromium and 0.5% molybdenum. The specification offers two classes that differ not in chemistry but in heat treatment condition: Class 1 is annealed for maximum ductility, and Class 2 is normalized and tempered for higher as-supplied strength. Choosing between them is a fundamental engineering decision based on the required design strength and the fabrication route.

the Two Classes

A387 Grade 5 Class 1 is supplied in the annealed, fully softened condition to maximize ductility and facilitate severe forming operations prior to final heat treatment. A387 Grade 5 Class 2 is supplied in the normalized and tempered condition, offering higher as-supplied strength for more efficient design while maintaining good toughness and corrosion resistance. Both classes have the identical chemical composition of approximately 5% chromium and 0.5% molybdenum; the difference is created entirely by the mill heat treatment.

Heat Treatment Difference

Class 1 is annealed by slow cooling from an appropriate temperature, producing a soft ferrite-pearlite microstructure that is stable, uniform, and easy to form or cold work in the shop. Class 2 is normalized by heating above the transformation range and air cooling to refine the grain structure, then tempered at a sub-critical temperature to achieve the optimal combination of strength and ductility, producing a stronger, more refined microstructure. After fabrication, welded vessels of both classes receive a final post-weld heat treatment; for Class 2 the PWHT must be controlled so that it does not under-temper the base metal, typically being performed at a temperature no higher than the original tempering temperature.

Mechanical Properties Compared

The mechanical requirements differ clearly between the classes. Class 1 has a tensile strength range of 415-585 MPa (60-85 ksi) and a minimum yield strength of 205 MPa (30 ksi), with lower typical hardness around 201 HB maximum. Class 2 has a tensile strength range of 485-620 MPa (70-90 ksi) and a minimum yield strength of 310 MPa (45 ksi), with typical hardness of about 149-217 HB. The key difference is roughly 50% higher yield strength in Class 2, which allows thinner sections or higher pressure ratings in the as-supplied condition, while Class 1 offers lower strength but higher ductility and easier cold forming.

Fabrication and PWHT Considerations

Class 1 is often preferred for complex or severe cold forming operations such as deep dished heads, because the softer material is less likely to crack during forming; after forming, the entire vessel receives a final PWHT that establishes the final properties uniformly. Class 2 may require more care during cold forming, but its as-supplied properties are closer to the final design condition, which can simplify qualification. Welding A387 Grade 5 requires stringent procedures because of its alloy content: mandatory preheating is typically applied in the range of 175-250 degrees Celsius, with strict interpass temperature control to prevent hard, crack-sensitive microstructures. A mandatory post-weld heat treatment in the range of 675-730 degrees Celsius is essential to temper the weld zone, relieve residual stress, and restore corrosion resistance.

How to Choose Between Class 1 and Class 2

Choose Class 1 when the component requires significant cold forming or shaping in the shop, when the design does not require the higher strength of Class 2, or when the entire fabricated vessel will undergo a final PWHT that will establish the final properties uniformly. Choose Class 2 when higher as-supplied strength is needed for the design, allowing weight savings or higher pressure ratings, when the fabrication involves standard welding and moderate forming, or when material properties closer to the final design specification are wanted upfront. In either case, the designer selects the starting condition based on the allowable design stresses in the applicable code and the fabrication needs, since both classes end with a final PWHT that harmonizes the properties of the weldment.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between A387 Grade 5 Class 2 and Class 1? The difference is entirely in the heat treatment condition and the resulting mechanical properties. Class 1 is annealed for maximum ductility and formability, while Class 2 is normalized and tempered for higher as-supplied strength. The chemical composition is identical.

Do the two classes have the same chemical composition? Yes. Both classes have the identical composition of approximately 5% chromium and 0.5% molybdenum, as defined by ASTM A387 Grade 5. The mechanical difference is created by the mill heat treatment.

What are the mechanical properties of each class? Class 1 has a tensile strength of 415-585 MPa (60-85 ksi) and a minimum yield strength of 205 MPa (30 ksi). Class 2 has a tensile strength of 485-620 MPa (70-90 ksi) and a minimum yield strength of 310 MPa (45 ksi).

When should Class 1 be selected? Class 1 is selected when the component requires significant cold forming in the shop, when the higher strength of Class 2 is not required by the design, or when the entire vessel will receive a final PWHT that establishes the final properties uniformly.

Is post-weld heat treatment required for both classes? Yes. PWHT is always required after welding for A387 Grade 5. For Class 2, the PWHT must be controlled so that it does not under-temper the base metal, typically at a temperature no higher than the original tempering temperature.

What temperature range is A387 Grade 5 suitable for? The grade is used for elevated-temperature pressure vessel service, commonly in the range of about 540-600 degrees Celsius, where its oxidation resistance and high-temperature strength exceed those of lower-alloyed grades. The governing design code should be consulted for allowable stresses at the design temperature.

Send Inquiry