
SA514 Grade E is a high-strength, quenched and tempered alloy steel plate with a minimum yield strength of 100 ksi (690 MPa) for thicknesses up to 1.25 inches. It achieves its strength through a higher alloy content, including elements like chromium, molybdenum, and often boron, which provide excellent hardenability and through-thickness properties, but it requires strict welding procedures due to its higher carbon equivalent.
SA514 Grade F is a modified version of Grade E, offering the same 100 ksi minimum yield strength but with a leaner alloy chemistry (lower carbon and no boron). This results in a significantly lower carbon equivalent, greatly improving weldability and reducing the risk of cracking during fabrication, making it the preferred choice for complex, heavily welded structures.

The difference between SA514 Grade E and Grade F within the ASTM A514/A514M standard for high-strength quenched and tempered alloy steel plate lies primarily in chemical composition and the resulting hardenability and weldability, while their minimum mechanical strength properties are identical for common thicknesses.
Here is a detailed, point-by-point comparison:
| Feature | SA514 Grade E | SA514 Grade F |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Distinction | Standard / Conventional Alloy | Restricted Alloy / Improved Weldability |
| Key Alloying Elements | Higher Carbon (C), Chromium (Cr), Molybdenum (Mo), and often contains Boron (B). | Lower Carbon (C) and lower levels of other alloying elements. No Boron (B) addition. |
| Carbon Content (Max, %) | 0.23% (typically higher, ~0.20%) | 0.20% (typically lower, ~0.16%) |
| Carbon Equivalent (CE) | Higher (typically ~0.75-0.85) | Lower (typically ~0.60-0.70) |
| Mechanical Properties | ||
| - Yield Strength (≤ 1.25") | 100 ksi (690 MPa) | 100 ksi (690 MPa) |
| - Tensile Strength | 110-130 ksi (760-895 MPa) | 110-130 ksi (760-895 MPa) |
| - Impact Toughness | Charpy V-notch @ -50°F (-46°C) | Charpy V-notch @ -50°F (-46°C) |
| Core Difference | Achieves strength primarily through alloy content & Boron hardenability. | Achieves strength through a modified Q&T process with leaner chemistry. |
| Weldability | More challenging. Higher CE requires stricter controls: higher pre-heat, strict low-H₂ procedures, often mandatory PWHT. More prone to HAZ cracking. | Significantly better. Lower CE means less sensitivity to HAZ hardening and cracking. Allows for lower pre-heat temps and is more forgiving during welding. |
| Hardenability | Very high, due to Boron. Excellent through-thickness properties. | Sufficient for the grade, but without Boron's extreme effect. |
| Typical Applications | Used where ultimate strength and through-thickness properties are paramount, and sophisticated welding is feasible. | Preferred for complex fabrications with extensive welding, where weldability is a primary concern to reduce cost and risk. |
| Common Reference | Often called "T1" steel (the original grade). | Often called "T1 Type F" or "Modified T1." |
Why Do Two Grades with the Same Strength Exist?
The creation of Grade F was a direct response to fabricator demand. While Grade E provides phenomenal strength, its high alloy content makes welding difficult, expensive, and prone to cracking if procedures aren't perfect.
Grade F was engineered to provide the same 100 ksi yield strength but with a chemistry that is inherently less crack-sensitive during welding. This is quantified by its lower Carbon Equivalent (CE) value.
How to Choose: Grade E vs. Grade F
The choice is fundamentally a trade-off between alloy robustness and weldability/fabrication cost.
Choose SA514 Grade E when:
The application is critical and the highest level of through-thickness strength/hardenability is needed.
The design involves minimal welding, or the welding is straightforward on thick sections.
You are replacing existing Grade E in a design or following a legacy specification.
Choose SA514 Grade F when:
Weldability is the top priority. The fabrication involves complex, extensive welding.
You want to reduce fabrication costs by allowing lower pre-heat temperatures, less stringent procedures, and potentially eliminating post-weld heat treatment (PWHT).
You are designing a new structure where the improved weldability lowers overall risk of fabrication defects.
Key Takeaway
SA514 Grade E and Grade F are "equal in strength but different in chemistry." Think of them as two paths to the same destination (100 ksi yield):
Grade E takes the "high-alloy, high-hardenability" path.
Grade F takes the "leaner-alloy, better-weldability" path.
For any new project involving significant fabrication, Grade F is often the preferred modern choice due to its easier welding characteristics, unless there is a specific reason requiring the chemistry of Grade E. Always consult with your steel supplier and welding engineer when making the final selection.
1. What Is SA514 Grade E Steel?
SA514 Grade E is a high-strength, quenched and tempered alloy steel plate within the ASTM A514/SA514 specification, designed for applications requiring a balance of high yield strength and excellent toughness.
2. What Is The Yield Strength Of SA514 Grade E?
The minimum yield strength of SA514 Grade E is 100 ksi (690 MPa) for thicknesses up to 2.5 inches (63.5 mm). For thicker plates, the minimum yield strength decreases.
3. What Is The Difference Between SA514 Grade E And Grade F?
The primary difference is the chemical composition. Grade E typically contains different levels of alloying elements (like Chromium, Molybdenum, and Boron) compared to Grade F, which can affect hardenability, weldability, and specific application suitability, though both have a 100 ksi min yield.
4. Is SA514 Grade E Weldable?
Yes, but with strict procedures. It requires preheating, the use of low-hydrogen electrodes, and controlled heat input to prevent cracking and maintain mechanical properties in the heat-affected zone (HAZ).
5. What Is SA514 Grade E Used For?
It is used in highly stressed structural components for heavy construction and mining equipment, such as crane booms, excavator arms, and frames where extreme strength and toughness are required.
6. What Is The Chemical Composition Of SA514 Grade E?
Its typical composition includes Carbon (~0.15-0.21%), Manganese (~0.80-1.10%), Silicon (~0.40-0.80%), Chromium (~0.50-0.80%), Molybdenum (~0.18-0.28%), Vanadium (~0.03-0.08%), and Boron (0.0005-0.005%).
7. What Is The Hardness Of SA514 Grade E?
The typical Brinell hardness range for SA514 Grade E is 235-293 HBW (approximately 22-30 HRC), similar to other grades like Grade F, as it is also a quenched and tempered steel.
8. How Does SA514 Grade E Compare To T1 Steel?
SA514 Grade E is a type of T1 steel. "T1" is the historic tradename for A514/SA514 quenched and tempered steels. Grade E is one specific chemical composition variant under this standard.
9. Can SA514 Grade E Be Flame Cut?
Yes, it can be flame cut, but it requires a controlled process. Preheating before cutting and slow, controlled cooling (often by using heating torches) are necessary to prevent the formation of hard, crack-sensitive zones along the cut edge.
10. What Is The Equivalent Of SA514 Grade E In Europe?
There is no direct, identical European equivalent. The closest grades in terms of high strength and quenched & tempered condition are S690QL or S690QL1 (EN 10025-6), though their chemical compositions differ.
Full specification and details are available on request. The above information is provided for guidance purposes only. For specific design requirements please contact our technical sales staff.


